
Angela Rayner’s housing department faces fresh questions as almost 20,000 second homes disappear from council tax records, leaving local authorities facing a £48 million shortfall in potential revenue.
Councils are discovering that doubling tax bills does not necessarily mean doubling their income, as thousands of second homes vanish from the tax register.
Thousands of second homes have disappeared from council tax records across England as owners face bills of up to twice the normal rate, raising serious questions about the financial consequences of a policy being rolled out under Labour.
New Government figures reveal that the number of properties officially classified as second homes has fallen by almost 20,000 in just two years, potentially depriving local authorities of £48 million in additional annual council tax revenue compared with what they could have collected had property numbers remained unchanged.
Figures published by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government on Wednesday (November 18) show that England had 260,446 registered second homes in October 2026, compared with 279,870 in 2024.
That represents a reduction of 19,424 properties, including 7,448 over the past year.
The figures come as councils across England increasingly impose a 100 per cent council tax premium on second homes, effectively doubling the annual charge for affected properties.
The powers were introduced through the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 and became available to local authorities in April 2025, under Labour.
They were designed to discourage properties being left unused for much of the year and encourage more homes to return to permanent residential occupation.
But the latest figures expose a difficult financial question for Labour ministers and local authorities: what happens when the properties expected to generate additional tax revenue begin disappearing from the system?
According to calculations reported by The Telegraph, councils could have billed approximately £453 million in second-home premiums in 2026-27 if the number of properties had remained at its 2024 level.
With fewer homes now registered, that estimated figure falls to approximately £405 million.
The difference amounts to £48 million in potential annual revenue.
Meanwhile, the number of councils imposing the premium has continued to rise.
Of England’s 296 billing authorities, 246 have introduced the additional charge, leaving just 50 without it.
A total of 176,365 second homes are now subject to the premium, approximately 68 per cent of all properties officially classified as second homes.
That is around 6,000 more properties paying the additional charge than a year earlier, despite the overall number of registered second homes falling.
Some areas have experienced particularly dramatic reductions.
According to The Telegraph’s analysis, Crawley has seen a 78 per cent fall in registered second homes since 2024, while Welwyn Hatfield recorded a 68 per cent decrease and Castle Point a 66 per cent reduction.
However, the disappearance of properties from the second-home category does not necessarily mean they have been sold to families looking for somewhere to live.
Property specialists warn that some owners have changed how their properties are used or classified, including moving qualifying holiday accommodation into the business-rates system.
Others have sold their properties as the combined costs of council tax, stamp duty and ongoing maintenance make ownership increasingly expensive.
The distinction is important because a reduction in registered second homes does not, by itself, demonstrate that local families have gained access to more housing.
And for councils already struggling to balance their budgets, it creates uncertainty over the amount of additional income the premium can reliably generate.
The developments come against a backdrop of rising council tax bills for households across England.
The average Band D council tax bill reached £2,392 in 2026-27, an increase of £111, or 4.9 per cent, compared with the previous financial year.
In Dorset, some owners of Band H second homes face annual bills exceeding £11,000.
The premium also raises wider questions about the impact on communities where holiday accommodation and second-home ownership contribute to local economies, including through spending in shops, restaurants and hospitality businesses.
Supporters of the charge argue that second homes can reduce the supply of permanent housing in popular locations, particularly coastal and rural communities where local residents struggle to afford property.
But the latest figures demonstrate that higher tax rates can change property owners’ behaviour in ways that complicate councils’ financial forecasts.
For Labour ministers, the challenge is now to establish whether the expanding use of the premium is genuinely increasing access to permanent housing, whether it is delivering sustainable revenue for councils, and what effect it is having on local economies.
With thousands of properties no longer officially classified as second homes, those are questions the Government cannot answer simply by pointing to the number of councils doubling the tax.


