Andy Burnham’s Labour Government wants 16-year-olds to help decide who runs the country, yet its proposed employment rules would require parental approval and council permits for those still of compulsory school age to take a Saturday job.
Welcome to the madhouse of modern Labour, where democracy is encouraged but earning your own money comes with a permission slip.
Just when you think this Labour Government has reached the absolute limits of political stupidity, along comes another proposal so gloriously, magnificently absurd that you begin to wonder whether Whitehall has become the headquarters of some elaborate national practical joke.
Apparently, 16-year-olds are mature enough to help choose the Prime Minister, determine the political direction of the United Kingdom and influence decisions involving hundreds of billions of pounds of taxpayers’ money. But should a 16-year-old who has not yet reached compulsory school-leaving age fancy earning a few quid serving tea and sandwiches on a Saturday morning? Good heavens! Not without parental approval, a council permit and the appropriate paperwork.
You can help decide who commands Britain’s Armed Forces, but apparently handing someone a bacon sandwich is a matter for the local authority.
Welcome to Labour’s Britain, where the ballot box is open to teenagers but the Saturday job comes with a bureaucratic obstacle course.
Under the Government’s Representation of the People Bill, 16 and 17-year-olds would gain the right to vote in Westminster elections. Meanwhile, the Department for Education is consulting on a national child employment framework under which employers would need council permits to employ children who have not yet reached compulsory school-leaving age, including some 16-year-olds.
The proposed application arrangements include parental approval, details of the work involved and confirmation of suitable safety assessments.
Yes, local employment permits already exist in many areas, and the proposed reforms would also relax some restrictions on working hours. The Government says the changes will improve consistency and safeguarding. But ministers are choosing to make council permits a statutory national requirement rather than asking whether the system could be made simpler.
And that is where the political absurdity lies.
Labour wants teenagers to exercise political power while continuing to subject some of their earliest opportunities to earn money to a system of official permission.
One might reasonably ask whether anybody in this Government has ever experienced the real world outside a council meeting, a political campaign or a publicly funded committee.
Because Britain’s small businesses are already being battered from every direction. Higher employers’ National Insurance contributions, rising wage bills, crippling energy costs and a mountain of regulation have made running a business increasingly difficult. Now, alongside all those pressures, the Government wants a national statutory permit system governing the employment of school-age teenagers.
Imagine being a small café owner, already working 60 hours a week simply to keep the lights on, when an enthusiastic youngster walks through the door asking for a few hours’ work.
In a sensible country, you would establish that the work was suitable, the hours reasonable, the parents supportive and the environment safe. Then you would give the youngster a chance.
In Labour’s Britain, the answer apparently begins with a form.
And therein lies the sickness at the heart of this Government. It seems to regard the British people as a population requiring constant supervision rather than individuals capable of making responsible decisions.
Everything must be regulated, recorded, inspected, licensed or approved. Nothing can simply be allowed to happen without somebody in authority satisfying themselves that the correct procedure has been followed.
It is the dead hand of bureaucracy dressed up as enlightened government.
The tragedy is that the people who suffer most from this mentality are often the very people Labour claims to champion.
A Saturday job is not merely a way of earning pocket money. It is where young people learn punctuality, responsibility, discipline and the enormous satisfaction of receiving their first wages. It is where they discover that money is earned through effort, that customers expect decent service and that employers cannot pay wages out of thin air.
These lessons are worth more than a thousand government lectures about aspiration.
Yet here we have an administration that appears far more enthusiastic about extending the electorate than about removing obstacles to employment.
There is something profoundly backward about that.
Britain desperately needs young people who want to work, create businesses, develop new technologies and build something for themselves. We need the next generation of engineers, entrepreneurs, inventors and industrialists. We need young people who look at the world and see opportunities, rather than obstacles.
What we do not need is another generation being taught that the first step towards doing anything worthwhile is to ask the Government for permission.
Of course children must be protected from exploitation and dangerous working conditions. Nobody with an ounce of sense would argue otherwise. But protecting children should not become an excuse for making perfectly ordinary, safe employment more complicated than necessary.
And this exposes the fundamental contradiction in Labour’s political philosophy.
When a teenager wants to influence the direction of government, ministers celebrate their maturity and independence. When that same teenager, still of compulsory school age, wants to gain some financial independence, the state insists on supervising the arrangements.
Political participation? Absolutely.
Economic independence? Please complete the paperwork.
It is an extraordinary set of priorities for a government that constantly lectures the country about growth, opportunity and aspiration.
Perhaps Prime Minister Andy Burnham could explain why his Government believes 16-year-olds should help decide who runs Britain while still requiring official permission for some of them to undertake the most ordinary part-time jobs.
And perhaps he could explain why, at a time when Britain urgently needs to encourage enterprise, the Government’s instinct is to preserve and nationalise a system of council permits rather than find ways to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy.
Because no amount of ministerial rhetoric about opportunity will compensate for an economic culture in which initiative is met with administrative hurdles.
Our country did not become a world leader in industry, science, commerce and innovation because generations of British entrepreneurs obediently waited for permission from Whitehall.
It became successful because people were prepared to work, take risks, innovate and build businesses.
The wealth that pays for our hospitals, schools and public services does not originate in government departments. It is created by people getting out of bed in the morning, opening their shops, employing staff, developing products and taking the financial risks that politicians rarely seem to appreciate.
And the earlier young people understand that, the better.
So here is a suggestion for Mr Burnham and his colleagues. Instead of endlessly dreaming up new ways to supervise ordinary life, why not concentrate on making Britain a country where it is easier to work, easier to hire, easier to start a business and easier to succeed?
Why not show some faith in parents, responsible employers and young people themselves?
Why not recognise that genuine empowerment comes not merely from putting a cross on a ballot paper, but from having the freedom and opportunity to make something of your life?
Labour seems determined to offer young people the power to help choose the people who govern them while remaining remarkably reluctant to loosen the state’s grip on their everyday lives.
That is not a vision of a confident, independent, entrepreneurial nation. It is the philosophy of a government that simply cannot bear the thought of people getting on with things without official oversight.
The British people deserve better. Our businesses deserve better. And the next generation certainly deserves better.
If a 16-year-old is mature enough to help choose the Prime Minister, surely this country can devise a sensible, straightforward way for them to work a Saturday shift without making the process an administrative expedition.
Because Britain’s future will not be built by the politicians who write the regulations.
It will be built by the youngsters who turn up for work.
And perhaps the greatest absurdity of all is that Labour seems to understand the value of their votes far better than the value of their work.





