Thursday 19th November 2026 13:11pm
Home Opinion LABOUR PUTS BRUSSELS BEFORE BRITISH JOBS AS BURNHAM PREPARES NEW EU YOUTH...

LABOUR PUTS BRUSSELS BEFORE BRITISH JOBS AS BURNHAM PREPARES NEW EU YOUTH DEAL

17/11/2026. London, United Kingdom. Prime Minister Andy Burnham prepares for a Parliamentary statement in his office in 10 Downing Street. Picture by Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street
Advertisement Buy Now

GREAT BRITISH PAC has accused Labour of putting its obsession with Brussels ahead of the employment prospects of Britain’s young people, as Prime Minister Andy Burnham prepares to negotiate a new EU youth mobility agreement despite mounting evidence of a jobs crisis at home.

The Prime Minister travels to Brussels on Friday, November 20, for a major UK-EU summit, where an agreement allowing thousands of young Europeans to live, work and study in Britain is under discussion.

Yet with job vacancies collapsing, businesses warning about the spiralling cost of employment and nearly a million young people already outside education, employment or training, the Government has not published an assessment demonstrating what the proposed agreement would mean for British jobseekers.

Great British PAC is demanding answers before any agreement is signed.

The warning comes as official figures reveal that UK job vacancies fell by another 22,000 to 690,000 in the three months to October, the lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014.

It also follows the publication of Labour’s own commissioned review into the youth employment crisis, which recommends a new test requiring government decisions to be assessed against their impact on the employment prospects of the next generation.

But while Labour commissions reviews into why British youngsters cannot find work, its Prime Minister is preparing to negotiate a new arrangement potentially opening the same struggling labour market to thousands more overseas applicants.

Where is the impact assessment? Where are the safeguards? And why should the British public trust Labour to protect young people’s futures when ministers have not demonstrated that their own proposed deal would pass the test recommended by their own review?

Britain’s jobs crisis: the warning Labour cannot ignore

The latest Office for National Statistics figures paint a deeply worrying picture.

Job vacancies have fallen for three consecutive quarters, with the number of available positions now below pre-pandemic levels.

Small businesses, traditionally an important source of entry-level employment, are struggling with rising costs and weakening confidence.

The warnings are particularly stark for young people seeking their first opportunity to enter the workforce.

James Reed, chief executive of recruitment giant Reed, told Times Radio this week that allowing more people to compete for an already shrinking number of jobs could make matters worse.

Asked whether rejoining the European Union would improve employment prospects for young people, Reed said he did not believe it would pass the test proposed in Labour’s youth employment review.

His reasoning was straightforward: Britain already has a jobs crisis, and increasing competition for fewer vacancies would not necessarily improve opportunities.

Reed was commenting on full EU membership rather than providing a specific assessment of the proposed youth mobility agreement.

Nevertheless, his warning raises a question the Government must answer: what would the agreement actually mean for young British people already struggling to get a foot on the employment ladder?

No published assessment has demonstrated whether the proposed scheme would increase opportunities, depress wages in particular sectors or intensify competition for entry-level jobs.

Nor has the Government provided a published sector-by-sector analysis setting out where any additional workers might be employed.

The PAC believes the absence of that information is unacceptable.

Labour’s own jobs test comes back to haunt it

The contradiction is particularly striking because Labour itself commissioned Alan Milburn’s review into the crisis facing young people who are not in education, employment or training.

The review recommends a youth opportunity test, requiring policymakers to consider whether decisions will improve or diminish the next generation’s prospects of finding work.

It warns that individual government decisions may each have their own justification, but employers experience their combined impact through higher costs, greater complexity and increased risk.

That warning comes after changes to employer National Insurance contributions increased costs for businesses, adding to concerns about the affordability of recruitment.

Yet just days after the review’s publication, the Prime Minister is preparing to negotiate arrangements affecting access to Britain’s labour market without publishing evidence showing how the scheme would measure up against that recommended test.

Great British PAC says Labour cannot claim to champion the employment prospects of young Britons while refusing to demonstrate how one of its most significant negotiations could affect them.

Claire Bullivant: ‘Britain’s young people are not bargaining chips for Brussels’

Claire Bullivant, CEO of Great British PAC, said:

“Andy Burnham needs to get his priorities straight. Nearly a million young people are outside education, employment or training, job vacancies are at their lowest level in more than a decade, and businesses are struggling with the cost of taking on staff. Yet instead of putting British youngsters first, this Labour Government is heading to Brussels to negotiate greater access to our jobs market without showing the British public what the consequences might be.

“This is not a government putting Britain first. It is a government that appears more interested in pleasing Brussels than answering the legitimate concerns of British families.

“Labour has made employing people more expensive, watched opportunities shrink and now expects young British workers to take its assurances on trust. Well, trust is not good enough. Where is the evidence? Where are the safeguards? Where is the guarantee that this deal will not make an already desperate situation worse?

“Let me make something absolutely clear to Andy Burnham: the future of Britain’s young people is not a bargaining chip to be traded away in Brussels.

“If this deal is so wonderful, publish the figures, publish the full terms and put it before Parliament. And if Labour cannot demonstrate that it will benefit British workers, it has absolutely no business signing it.

“Britain’s young people deserve a Prime Minister who fights for their future, not one who gambles with it.”

A backdoor to freedom of movement?

The proposed Youth Experience Scheme has also raised serious questions about the Government’s commitment to maintaining the UK’s post-Brexit immigration arrangements.

Under terms reported from draft negotiations, young adults aged 18 to 34 could potentially be permitted to live, work and study in Britain or the European Union for periods of up to three years.

The Government has insisted that the scheme would be time-limited, visa-based and subject to restrictions, including on access to benefits and dependants.

However, the precise numerical limits and enforcement mechanisms remain the subject of negotiations.

Reports have suggested disagreement over whether Britain should have a binding annual cap or whether an alternative arrangement involving reviews and an emergency brake would be acceptable to Brussels.

Great British PAC believes any agreement must include a clear, legally enforceable annual limit rather than a mechanism that allows numbers to be challenged only after they have risen.

The organisation also wants the Government to explain how the scheme would differ in practice from the wider freedom of movement arrangements that British voters chose to leave behind.

The question has become more pressing as senior Labour figures publicly advocate a longer-term return to the European Union.

Former deputy prime minister David Lammy has called for Labour to approach the next general election with an explicit commitment to rejoining.

Although Burnham insists that his Government’s current negotiating red lines remain in place, Great British PAC believes the public is entitled to know whether Friday’s agreement is intended as a limited arrangement or another step towards reversing Brexit.

And what is the bill for British taxpayers?

The employment consequences are not the only questions surrounding Labour’s negotiations.

Britain has already agreed to return to the EU’s Erasmus+ programme for the 2027/28 academic year, at an estimated UK contribution of £570 million.

That contribution relates to Erasmus+, not the proposed Youth Experience Scheme, and the two arrangements must not be confused.

However, wider negotiations have also raised questions about potential financial concessions concerning university tuition fees and the NHS immigration health surcharge.

The EU has pressed for more favourable tuition fee arrangements for European students, while reports have suggested that British universities could require Treasury compensation if they lose income from international fees.

There have also been proposals concerning exemptions from the NHS surcharge for young people participating in the mobility scheme.

The final financial consequences of these potential concessions have not been publicly established.

Great British PAC says taxpayers deserve a full breakdown before ministers make binding commitments.

With public finances under pressure and businesses facing higher employment costs, it is unacceptable for the Government to negotiate potentially expensive arrangements without explaining the costs and benefits to Parliament and the public.

British young people must not be pushed to the back of the queue

Labour has announced plans to extend employment support for young people, including a Jobs Guarantee intended to help 90,000 people who have been out of work.

Burnham has indicated that publicly funded places under that scheme would be directed towards young people in Britain rather than participants arriving through the proposed EU arrangement.

But the detailed eligibility rules have not yet been published.

Moreover, assurances relating to subsidised employment schemes do not answer the broader question of what additional competition might mean for ordinary vacancies in shops, hospitality businesses, offices and other sectors where young people traditionally begin their careers.

There may be benefits to reciprocal youth mobility, including opportunities for British young people to work and study in Europe.

But those possible benefits do not remove the Government’s obligation to assess the potential effects on domestic employment.

British workers deserve evidence, not ministerial assurances.

GREAT BRITISH PAC DEMANDS SEVEN ANSWERS BEFORE ANY DEAL IS SIGNED

Great British PAC is calling on the Prime Minister to:

1. Publish the full proposed Youth Experience Scheme, including its age range, visa conditions, duration, numerical limits and safeguards, before signing an agreement.

2. Release a comprehensive youth employment impact assessment examining the likely effects on British vacancies, wages, entry-level recruitment and young people’s employment opportunities.

3. Secure a legally enforceable annual cap on participants, with independent monitoring and transparent reporting to Parliament.

4. Publish the eligibility rules for taxpayer-funded youth employment schemes, ensuring their intended beneficiaries are clearly protected.

5. Disclose the full financial consequences of the UK-EU package, including the confirmed Erasmus+ contribution and any proposed commitments involving university fees or NHS surcharge exemptions.

6. Guarantee parliamentary scrutiny and a vote on the final agreement before implementation, with the full text available to MPs in advance.

7. Establish independent annual monitoring of employment outcomes for young British people, including the progress of the Government’s Jobs Guarantee.

Britain deserves answers before Brussels gets an agreement

The issue is not whether young British people should have opportunities to travel, study or work abroad.

The issue is whether their own Government is prepared to defend their interests at home.

Labour has commissioned a review warning about the employment crisis facing Britain’s young people. It has acknowledged the need to create opportunities and promised action to help those who have been left behind.

Yet its Prime Minister is preparing for a major negotiation affecting access to the British labour market without publishing the assessment that would allow the public to judge its likely consequences.

If Labour believes its proposed agreement will create jobs, raise prosperity and deliver better prospects for young British workers, it should have no difficulty publishing the evidence.

If it cannot produce that evidence, it should not expect Britain to sign a blank cheque.

Britain’s young people need jobs, not another Labour public relations exercise. And they deserve a Government that puts their future before another political deal with Brussels.

2 COMMENTS

  1. History won’t be kind to all the people that tried to stop brexit. Probably quite soon the Euro will crash and most countries will leave the EU, proving that leaving the EU was 100% right. The wisdom of the crowd is always right

  2. The good news is that Labour M.P’s will bear alot of the blame for trying to stop brexit. It was only the Conservatives that respected the will of the British people.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here