Thursday 19th November 2026 13:11pm
Home Opinion ‘Out of the EU, but paying them money’: the deal Labour won’t...

‘Out of the EU, but paying them money’: the deal Labour won’t let you read before it becomes law

12/11/2026. Antalya, Turkey. Prime Minister Andy Burnham attends COP31 in Türkiye. Picture by Lauren Hurley / No 10 Downing Street
Advertisement Buy Now

Andy Burnham goes to Brussels on Friday to sign a package of agreements that would bind Britain to EU rules on food and farming, tie British industry to the EU carbon market, and open a youth mobility route for tens of thousands of young Europeans each year.

The Prime Minister will do it without publishing the legal text of a single one of those agreements, without publishing the Treasury modelling behind his £17bn growth claim, and without publishing the carbon payment schedule, the reported exit penalty or the youth scheme’s quotas.

And the bill that turns all of it into British law, the European Partnership Bill, could be before the Commons within days.

That is not a reset. It is a signature on a contract the country has not been allowed to read. Parliament is being asked to hand over a standing power to adopt rules Britain will neither write nor amend, in many cases without a vote. Great British PAC says ministers must publish the texts, the numbers and the terms before any MP is asked to approve them.

What Labour promised, and what it is signing

Labour’s 2024 manifesto ruled out a return to the single market, the customs union and freedom of movement. The BBC reports that Keir Starmer said Britain would not rejoin in his lifetime.

Andy Burnham did not fight that election and does not feel bound by it. In September he told his party conference, as UK in a Changing Europe records, that “Brexit has done more harm than good”. That may be honest, but honesty about the destination does not give him a mandate for the terms.

Those terms are extraordinary. The BBC reports that in exchange for scrapping export health certificates and border checks, Britain would commit to “observing and adapting to existing EU regulations on plant, animal and food trade standards”, a process known as dynamic alignment. Britain would follow EU rules as they change, with no vote and no veto.

The Guardian reports that Britain would pay the EU billions for emissions trading access. The Times reports a multimillion-pound penalty if a future government walks away.

Neither document has been published. No minister has confirmed either figure.

Labour’s own former ministers are pushing for re-entry

The most damaging interventions are not coming from the Opposition.

David Lammy, the former foreign secretary and deputy prime minister, wrote in The Times on 18 November that Labour should go into the next election promising to rejoin, with a referendum on the terms. The Telegraph reports his argument that the customs union does not deliver major growth, that the single market without membership brings growth “with little influence over the rules we follow”, and that “only membership answers all three questions”.

Peter Kyle, the former business secretary, went further. He called a halfway option such as the customs union or single market a “non-starter”, because “it would be seen as a stepping stone to full membership which, for most supporters, it would be. So let’s get quickly to the real choice we face: in or out.”

A former Labour business secretary regards half measures of this kind as a staging post, and wants his party to skip to the real question. Downing Street presents the package as a reset, while senior Labour figures are openly debating a return to EU membership.

Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, said Brexit had made Britain “poorer, weaker and less secure”.

Against them, the Chancellor John Healey has refused to echo Burnham’s wish to rejoin in his lifetime, and the Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy insists the debate is settled, The Telegraph reports.

So which is Government policy? The Prime Minister has not said. He says the public will be “the boss” and that there is “no rush”. He has not told voters what he actually wants.

What Britain would have to accept

UK in a Changing Europe describes the architecture ministers have not published.

Britain would get “decision-shaping” powers likely modelled on Switzerland’s: a voice in consultation, no vote when EU institutions adopt the rules it must then apply. That is the substance of the criticism, and it is separate from the domestic question. Parliament would still vote on the implementing bill, and on any statutory instruments it provided for. What it would not get is a say in the rules themselves.

The same briefing expects contributions to the EU agencies running the regimes, uncosted; a dispute process that will “almost certainly” include the Court of Justice of the European Union as the ultimate arbiter of the law Britain would apply, though no text yet confirms it; and a compensation clause for leaving, whose terms have not been published.

Ministers have also not published the schedule of powers they intend to take, so Parliament cannot yet see how much of this it would be asked to wave through. The Guardian reports the enabling bill will be introduced before Christmas, with legislation possibly laid next week. UK in a Changing Europe notes that a swift process would require sweeping powers to adopt EU law by secondary legislation, with “little or no ability to block it”.

THE COSTS THE GOVERNMENT WON’T PUBLISH

The Prime Minister’s case rests on a single number. He told the Economist, as The Guardian reported, that “a deal could add up to 0.4% to GDP”. The Government’s own published analysis, however, covers only food and carbon, and puts the gain at 0.3% of GDP by 2040, according to UK in a Changing Europe.

Those figures may measure different things over different periods. Nobody outside the Treasury can say, because the modelling has not been published. A benefit projected for 2040 cannot be sold as growth this Parliament, when the obligations begin next year.

Then there are the costs. The exit clause is reported but unpublished. The Guardian reports up to £450m a year on EU student fees under the most expensive scenario, a figure officials call speculative and which has since been deferred. Britain would pay for carbon access at a price not stated, and £570m for Erasmus+ in 2027/28.

There is no consolidated statement of what this adds up to, and no independent assessment. Chancellor, show the workings.

THE YOUTH SCHEME NOBODY HAS ASSESSED

The youth mobility scheme is the least scrutinised and most politically sensitive part of the package.

The Guardian reports a quota of about 100,000 a year expected to be settled, after Britain offered 50,000 then 80,000, against an EU demand of 100,000 to 150,000. The Telegraph reports an estimate of 80,000, with stays of up to three years. No final quota has been published, which is why this article cites a range rather than a figure.

The scheme would be reciprocal, and no impact assessment has been published. Three conditions remain unresolved: whether young Britons could work across the EU or in one country only, whether EU nationals would pay the immigration health surcharge, and how places would be divided between member states.

UK in a Changing Europe concludes a scheme would probably raise net immigration, with most participants working and paying tax, while cautioning that data on British movement the other way is patchy. Competition for entry-level jobs is a reasonable concern, not a measured outcome, and the Government is the only body able to settle it.

That is the point. A visa route of this size should be explained, costed and assessed before Parliament approves it, not discovered in a communiqué afterwards.

GREAT BRITISH PAC REACTION

Steve Wright, Campaign Leader at Great British PAC, said:

“The public has been very clear that it does not accept the premise that Parliament should give up control of its laws, and does not accept increased competition for our unemployed youth. The government does not have a mandate for this activity, and the British public needs to ensure that their local MP knows it“

Great British PAC exists to defend sovereignty, democratic accountability and the interests of British taxpayers and workers. This deal touches all three, and it is being concluded behind a closed door.

GREAT BRITISH PAC DEMANDS

  1. Publish the full legal texts before the bill’s Second Reading.
  2. Publish the Treasury modelling behind the £17bn and 0.4% claims.
  3. Publish a five-year cost statement, certified by the OBR.
  4. Publish the withdrawal clause and cost the penalty.
  5. Publish which EU laws Parliament will vote on, and which it will not.
  6. Publish the youth scheme quota and an impact assessment.
  7. Tell the Commons whether this is the policy, or a step to rejoining.

THE JUDGEMENT

There is a decent deal buried in this package. British food exporters have been strangled by paperwork for six years, and fixing that is a legitimate job of government.

But fixing a veterinary certificate does not require permanent alignment with rules Britain cannot vote on. It does not require an unquantified carbon bill, a reported but unpublished exit penalty, or a visa quota settled in secret.

It should not require asking MPs to grant a standing power to adopt European law before they have read the agreements it implements.

Labour asked for a mandate to keep Britain out. It is now accepting EU rules over British food, farming and carbon, sector by sector, with no vote in Brussels and no veto over the rules themselves, and calling it a reset.

Publish the texts. Publish the costs. Let Parliament vote on the principle before the machinery is built.

If those texts are still unpublished when the bill reaches the Commons, every MP who backs it will be backing something they have not read, on behalf of people who were never asked.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here