Labour is preparing the biggest shake-up of policing since 1964 on a case it has not published, a review it has not released and a bill it cannot yet fully explain.
On Tuesday Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, is due to tell police chiefs at the APCC and NPCC partnership summit in Westminster that merging the 43 forces of England and Wales into eight or nine regional giants could leave 130,000 more crimes unsolved every year. The Conservatives’ own calculation, reported by The Telegraph, puts the figure at 135,188. Philp rounds it to 130,000 in extracts released ahead of the speech. Either way, it is a claim the Home Secretary must answer with evidence, not with a press release.
The stakes are already visible in the official statistics. The Home Office’s latest crime outcomes bulletin records around 4.4 million victim-based offences in the year to March 2026. Just 7.3 per cent resulted in a charge or summons. In 2016 the figure was 11.1 per cent. The collapse in outcomes is the central fact of policing in England and Wales, and it began long before this Home Secretary drew her new map. That does not absolve Labour. It raises the price of getting the answer wrong.
Shabana Mahmood’s reforms would abolish most of the 43 forces, replace them with a smaller number of regional forces, create local policing areas beneath them and build a National Police Service on top. The January white paper calls the 43-force model “no longer fit for purpose”. It promises fewer, larger forces, local policing areas “at the level of local towns, cities and boroughs”, and the abolition of police and crime commissioners in May 2028.
What it does not contain is a published cost for the mergers, a published review of the evidence, or a published answer to the question every chief constable, commissioner and taxpayer is now asking. If bigger is better, where is the proof?
A reorganisation built on an unpublished review
The independent review that will recommend the new force map was chaired by Lord Hogan-Howe, the former Metropolitan Police commissioner. According to The Guardian, it was completed in September and sent to the Home Secretary. It has still not been published. Government sources say it will appear before Christmas, with a white paper in the new year.
Its reported options range from eight or nine regional forces to around 20. One version would create nine regional forces in England plus a single force for Wales, sitting above more than 150 local policing units. Another would align forces with the new mayoral strategic authorities, of which there could be as many as 40.
This is not a technical adjustment. It would redraw the boundaries of every police force in England and Wales, abolish the directly elected posts that hold them to account, and concentrate control of budgets, specialists and back-office functions at a regional level. It is the sort of change that should arrive with a mountain of evidence and a queue of ministers willing to defend it in public.
Instead it has arrived with a delay, a leaked range of options and a wall of opposition from the people who currently run the system. More than 30 police and crime commissioners have voiced opposition, according to The Telegraph. The commissioners are not neutral bystanders. They have their jobs to defend. But they also have a democratic mandate, and the Government’s plan is to take it away from them.
The Home Secretary’s defenders will say the commissioners are defending a failed model. If that is true, the Government should publish the evidence that proves it. It has not.
The figure Labour cannot dismiss
Philp’s argument rests on a simple comparison. The Metropolitan Police, the largest force in the country, solves 6.7 per cent of crimes, second from bottom nationally, according to the Conservatives’ analysis. Cheshire, one of the smallest, solves 14.9 per cent, the best rate in England and Wales. If every force performed like the Met, the Conservatives calculate, 135,188 more offences would go unsolved each year.
“If everywhere has the same crime solve rate as the Met, the largest current force, 130,000 fewer crimes will be solved each year. Bigger is not better,” Philp will say, according to the extracts. “These mega-forces will be very remote from the communities they are supposed to serve and resources will inevitably be sucked away from rural areas and towns into large cities.”
The measure matters, and it has been described too loosely. The 6.7 per cent figure, as used by the Conservatives and reported by The Telegraph, is a force-level charge or summons outcome rate: the share of crimes recorded by the Metropolitan Police that end with a suspect charged or summonsed. It is not a detection or clear-up rate. A detection or clear-up rate counts every route by which an investigation is closed, including cautions, out of court disposals, evidential difficulties and cases where no suspect is ever identified. The two measures are not interchangeable and should never be used as though they were.
There is a second distinction. The national charge or summons rate published by the Home Office, 7.3 per cent in the year to March 2026, covers victim-based offences only. The Met’s 6.7 per cent is a single force figure, and the Conservatives’ analysis does not set out whether it uses precisely the same offence base, the same recording period or the same treatment of cases still under investigation. A strict like-for-like comparison would require all three to be aligned.
On the figures cited, the Met’s reported rate is numerically below the national figure. However, a definitive like-for-like comparison requires confirmation that both measures cover the same offences, reporting period and outcome definitions. The distance between the Met’s 6.7 per cent and Cheshire’s 14.9 per cent is starker, but it is subject to the same caveat. Anyone who presents that difference as a simple verdict on force size is overselling the evidence. But anyone who waves it away is avoiding the question the Home Secretary must answer: if size is not the driver, what is, and what does her reform do about it?
The Home Office knows this. “This way this data has been used is misleading, disregarding multiple factors that contribute to charges beyond force size,” a spokesman said. Gavin Stephens, chairman of the National Police Chiefs’ Council, went further. “It would be misleading and inaccurate to judge the impact of potential reforms by making assumptions based on individual force performance,” he said.
They are right about the method. Crime mix, recording practice, deprivation, victim engagement and the sheer volume of complex cases in a capital city all affect the rate. A force that polices rural Cheshire is not doing the same job as a force that polices Tottenham or Croydon.
But the same logic destroys the Government’s case for silence. If individual force performance cannot settle the question, then the Home Office must publish the modelling that can. It must show how mergers would change charge rates, response times, neighbourhood officer numbers and specialist capacity. It must show the assumptions, the sensitivity analysis and the alternatives it rejected. Ministers have published none of it.
That is the accountability gap at the heart of this reform. The Conservatives have produced a projection, with assumptions that can be tested. The Government has produced a slogan, with assumptions that cannot be seen.
What a merger means on a street in Cheshire, or a village in North Wales
Mark Roberts retired as chief constable of Cheshire this month. His force has 2,400 officers and, by his account, the highest charge rates in the country for all crime, sexual offences, online child abuse, violence against a person and violence with injury, and the second highest for rape.
“The bit that gives me concern is the notion that you have to be big to be good. There are smaller, very effective forces,” he said. “My fear is that we end up with neighbourhood policing stripped out.”
His warning is not sentimental. It is operational. Cheshire’s surveillance teams can pass intelligence to front-line officers with a single phone call. In a force covering millions of people, that call travels further, through more layers, with more competing priorities. Roberts fears resources would be sucked towards Manchester or Liverpool, leaving towns and villages with slower responses and fewer detectives.
The same fear runs through rural Britain. A merged force covering the north west would stretch from the Mersey to the Pennines, taking in Greater Manchester, Merseyside, Lancashire, Cheshire and Cumbria. Its chief constable would command a population of several million and a geography that ranges from inner-city estates to fell farms. The local policing areas are supposed to protect the connection to communities. But they are a promise in a white paper, not a statutory guarantee.
Matthew Scott, the Conservative police and crime commissioner for Kent, put the risk plainly. “They will spend a great deal of time tearing up the fabric of policing for a suboptimal outcome,” he said.
Then there is the democratic question. The white paper abolishes police and crime commissioners and transfers their powers to mayors where they exist, and to policing and crime boards made up of local council leaders where they do not. On paper, that keeps decisions local. In practice, it removes the only direct election in England and Wales that is exclusively about policing. Council leaders would exercise police governance without anyone having voted for them to do so. Mayors would gain another empire, and another set of priorities, without a separate mandate for the police budget.
The public may not mourn the passing of commissioners. Turnout in those elections has been poor. But low turnout is not an argument for deleting the vote. It is an argument for making the alternative more accountable, not less.
The Government was warned
This is not the first attempt to merge English and Welsh forces. In 2006 Charles Clarke, then Labour home secretary, wanted to replace the 43-force structure with 12 to 15 mega-constabularies. The plan was abandoned after fierce opposition from police authorities and chief constables. The Institute for Government records the decisive problem: the Government refused to provide enough money to equalise the council tax precepts that different forces charged.
That problem has not gone away. Policing is funded by a mix of central grant and local precept, and the gap between what different areas raise is one of the most divisive issues in the system. Merge a wealthy commuter force with a poor urban one and someone has to pay for the difference. The Government has promised to reform the funding formula. It has not published the new formula, the transition arrangements or the cost of equalisation.
Sir Stephen Watson, chief constable of Greater Manchester, has said “a couple of billion quid” will be needed to get mergers off the ground, according to the Institute for Government. That is a chief constable who supports reform. He is not a Tory critic talking up the bill.
The only firm figure the Government has put on the record is £340 million for setting up the National Police Service. It is a different project, a national force that would absorb the National Crime Agency, counter-terrorism policing and the College of Policing. “Overall, the setting up of the national police service is £340 million or so, two thirds of which I have already committed through the current spending review allocation,” Mahmood told the Home Affairs Committee in September. About a third, she said, would come from the next spending review.
So the one number ministers cite is not the cost of the mergers. It is the cost of a separate organisation, and it is not fully funded. The mergers themselves have no published price. The transition has no published timetable beyond a white paper and a bill. The savings are asserted, not audited.
Scotland shows why the evidence must come first
Both sides cite Scotland. The Scottish Police Authority says the creation of a single force in 2013 has saved £2.5 billion, with £200 million a year and 2.5 million hours of officer time released through greater efficiency. That is a serious argument for consolidation, and it deserves to be heard.
But Scotland also shows what happens when the transition is underfunded. The SPA has warned that a flat cash settlement would force officer numbers down to 15,600, the lowest since 2003-04, with 958 officers and 302 staff cut. “Given the extreme nature of the actions required to deliver these savings, a flat cash funding scenario is not achievable in year and would devastate the service,” it told the Scottish Parliament. Officer numbers have already fallen by more than 700 since 2022-23.
Scotland is not proof that mergers fail. Nor is it proof that they succeed. It is proof that structural reform without a credible workforce and funding plan ends with fewer officers, longer calls and a service under strain. If ministers want to cite Scotland, they should publish the Scottish-style transition costs for England and Wales, including the redundancies, the IT migration, the estate rationalisation, the pension liabilities and the equalisation bill.
They have not.
“Record lows” and the facts
The Government’s response to criticism is that crime is falling. “This is a classic example of the Conservative Party trying to rewrite history. This Labour Government has brought crime down to record lows,” a government source told The Telegraph.
The official figures are more complicated. The Crime Survey for England and Wales, published last month, estimated 9.7 million incidents of headline crime in the year to June 2026. That is no statistically significant change on the previous year. Fraud rose 11 per cent to 4.5 million incidents. Bank and credit account fraud rose 13 per cent to 2.8 million. Recorded sexual offences rose 4 per cent to 218,994. Recorded robbery rose 10 per cent to 88,282. Knife crime and firearms offences fell, and the long-term trend in violence and theft is down.
So the picture is mixed, not a triumph. Ministers are entitled to point to the falls. They are not entitled to claim a record low while fraud is rising by double digits and 4.4 million victim-based crimes produce a charge or summons in fewer than one case in 13.
If the Government believes its reforms will improve those numbers, it should say by how much, by when and measured how. That is what a serious business case does. It sets a test that can fail.
GREAT BRITISH PAC REACTION
Claire Bullivant, CEO, Great British PAC said:
“Labour is threatening to rip the heart out of local policing and replace it with a vast, centralised bureaucracy run from distant regional headquarters.
“People in our towns and villages don’t want policing decisions made hundreds of miles away by officials who have never walked their streets or understood their communities. They want officers who know their neighbourhoods, understand local problems and are accountable to the people they serve.
“Yet Labour appears determined to dismantle local police forces without publishing the evidence, explaining the full costs or demonstrating how this extraordinary upheaval will make a single community safer.
“And with Conservatives warning that these proposals could result in another 130,000 crimes going unsolved every year, the Government is playing a dangerous game with public safety.
“This is Labour all over. More centralisation, more bureaucracy, more power for Whitehall and less say for the ordinary British people who will be left paying the price.
“Let me make one thing absolutely clear. The police belong to the communities they protect, not to Labour ministers in Westminster.
“If Shabana Mahmood cannot prove these mergers will put more officers on our streets, catch more criminals and make our communities safer, she should abandon this reckless experiment.
“Britain needs stronger local policing, not the surrender of local policing to distant bureaucracies.”
GREAT BRITISH PAC DEMANDS
- Publish the Hogan-Howe review in full, before Christmas and before any decision.Release the report, its evidence base, the force-level modelling and any dissenting advice from panel members. Parliament and the public should not be asked to debate a map that has been kept in a drawer.
- Publish a fully costed business case for every merger option. It must cover IT, estates, pensions, redundancy, VAT, precept equalisation, transition management and contingency, with the £340 million National Police Service costs shown separately. The figures should be signed off by the Treasury and published alongside the review.
- Legislate for enforceable neighbourhood policing guarantees. Set minimum officer numbers per 1,000 residents in every local policing area, publish response times for emergency and priority calls, and place a statutory duty on chief constables to consult communities before changing local policing boundaries.
- Put any structural reform to a binding vote of the House of Commons. A substantive motion, not a statutory instrument, preceded by evidence sessions with the Home Affairs Committee and the National Audit Office. No force should be abolished without the explicit consent of elected MPs.
- Publish comparable force-level performance data every quarter. Charge and summons rates, outcome types, response times, 999 and 101 waits, neighbourhood officer numbers and crime severity, on a consistent basis. The public should be able to see whether a merger improves or degrades performance in their area.
- Commission an independent assessment before implementation, not after. Ask the National Audit Office and HM Inspectorate of Constabulary to test whether mergers deliver better outcomes, with published success measures, a review date and a break clause if they do not.
- Protect local democratic accountability and guard against centralisation. Do not abolish police and crime commissioners in 2028 until the replacement arrangements have been legislated, funded and tested. Publish board minutes, attendance, budgets and decisions, and require a local ballot wherever a merger crosses a mayoral boundary without local consent.
The choice Labour must now make
Labour inherited a broken outcomes system. It did not invent the collapse in charge rates, the backlog in courts or the hollowing out of neighbourhood policing. But it now owns the response, and its response so far is a reorganisation without a published case, a cost without a published figure and a promise of local policing without a legal guarantee.
The Home Secretary says the case for reform is as strong as it has ever been. Then she should make it. Publish the review. Publish the costs. Publish the modelling. Set out what success looks like, how it will be measured and what happens if the mergers fail. Give Parliament a vote and give communities a say.
If she will not, the public is entitled to conclude that the case is not strong enough to survive daylight.
Britain does not need another reorganisation designed in Whitehall and sold with a slogan. It needs police officers who answer calls, detectives who close cases, and a Government that can prove its reforms will put more criminals behind bars. On the evidence published so far, Labour has not made that case. It has only made the announcement.
The British people will pay for this either way. They deserve to see the bill before the decision, not after.





