Tuesday 17th November 2026 11:11am
Home Opinion Nine Pubs Tipped for Conversion for Every One Planned to Open, and...

Nine Pubs Tipped for Conversion for Every One Planned to Open, and Ministers Still Will Not Publish the Bill

Advertisement Buy Now

Last Orders for the Cavalry

UKHospitality warned that the average pub could face a business rates bill £4,500 higher in 2027/28 than in 2025/26, before Labour’s subsequent relief measures were announced. The relief Labour is counting on to answer that does not begin until 1 April 2027, the same day wage costs rise again. And after three announcements in ten months, no minister has published a worked example showing what a single publican will actually pay.

That is the charge against Andy Burnham’s Government, and the council files make it harder to answer. Research reported by The Telegraph as part of its Save Our Pubs campaign found that the planning search portal Plota had identified 543 applications to demolish pubs or convert them into homes or offices in the 12 months to the end of September, against 63 applications associated with proposed new openings. That is 8.6 applications to convert for every one to open.

In the same period the British Beer and Pub Association recorded 295 closures across England, Scotland and Wales, after 161 in the first quarter alone, almost two a day and 26 per cent more than in the same three months of 2025. The association forecasts about 360 closures and 5,000 job losses for the year.

These are the numbers against which the Prime Minister’s promise will be judged. In July he stood in a pub in Essex and said publicans “need to know that the cavalry is coming”. What has arrived is a 15 per cent rates relief, a set of measures legislated to begin in five months, and a refusal to say what any of it is worth at the bar.

The promise, and what is actually in force

On 27 January the Government announced a 15 per cent business rates relief for pubs and live music venues for 2026/27, as the House of Commons Library briefing on pub ratesrecords. That is the only pub-specific rates support in force during the year in which 295 pubs closed.

On 23 July, in his first week in Downing Street, Burnham added a further 20 per cent discount from 2027/28, which the Treasury says will save “the typical pub an estimated £1,100”, cover almost 32,000 venues and cost about £100 million a year, funded by reviewing reliefs for businesses that “do not make a positive contribution to local communities”.

On 28 October the Chancellor went further. John Healey told the Commons he was raising the pub relief from 15 per cent to 35 per cent for 2027/28 and 2028/29, and the departmental guidance issued to billing authorities on Budget day confirms the terms: the 15 per cent rate is kept for live music venues with a rateable value of £1 million or more, and the small business rates relief thresholds for qualifying retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England rise from £12,000 to £18,000, with relief tapering evenly to nothing at £21,000.

Those measures are real and should be described as such. A qualifying pub with a rateable value below £18,000 will pay no business rates from April 2027, subject to the aggregate thresholds that apply to ratepayers holding other properties. A pub between £18,000 and £21,000 will pay a reducing share. Government estimates reported by ICAEW put the effect at 70,000 more businesses taken out of rates, including about 3,500 pubs, with half of all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England paying nothing at all.

But nothing in the package helps a pub above £21,000 beyond the 35 per cent relief and a two-year freeze. The 35 per cent rate runs for two years only, with no published plan for the third. And none of the April 2027 measures reaches a publican this winter, when the bills land and the decisions get made.

The bill nobody will publish

Here is the arithmetic Labour will not put on paper.

The revaluation that took effect in April 2026 raised rateable values for public houses and pub restaurants by an average of 30 per cent, and by 70 per cent for pub restaurants with letting rooms, against 19.4 per cent across all properties in England. The 40 per cent retail, hospitality and leisure discount was withdrawn at the Autumn 2025 Budget that preceded it. Pubs were hit in both halves of the bill: valuations are set by the Valuation Office Agency, but the multipliers are set by ministers, as the Commons Library sets out.

UKHospitality’s analysis, published before either relief existed, projected that an average pub’s rates would be £4,500 higher in 2027/28 than in 2025/26 and £7,000 higher in 2028/29, a £12,900 increase over three years and a 76 per cent rise, even after the reduced multiplier and transitional relief. The Government’s £1,100 is a saving measured against a bill that has risen, not against the bill pubs paid two years ago. The two figures cannot simply be netted off, and that is the point: nobody outside the department can tell whether the average pub is better or worse off, because the department has never published the bills side by side.

Publicans can work through their own multipliers and rateable value, and many will. What they cannot do is test the ministerial claim that the typical pub is £1,100 better off, because the baseline behind it has not been published. The technical annex issued to billing authorities on Budget day sets out the multipliers, the mechanics of the relief, the freeze and the new thresholds. It contains no worked example for a pub showing the combined effect.

The Government has had since November 2025, when the new rateable values were issued, to produce that number. It has produced three press releases instead.

What it means at the bar

This is what the delay looks like in practice.

Phil Thorley, who runs Thorley Taverns in the south east, told the BBC that business rates would rise at 17 of his 18 sites, adding £62,000 a year to costs, and warned the Budget would be “the death knell to the British pub”. Elaine Wrigley, who runs the Atlas Bar in Manchester, saw her rateable value rise from £69,000 to £97,000 and called the package “smoke and mirrors”: “She may well have said it’s the lowest rate and the best support but it’s from the highest base.”

Iain Hoskins, who owns Ma Pub Group in Liverpool, said the July relief would help “chip away” at rising costs but questioned how many venues would benefit. “As always, the devil is in the detail,” he said. Steve Perez of Global Brands was blunter about the cut publicans were promised in July: “welcome, but this won’t make any material difference to any pub.”

Those are not lobbyists complaining about a difficult market. They are the people the Prime Minister said the cavalry was riding to rescue, describing a bill that has risen faster than the relief attached to it.

The planning files

The planning system tells the same story in slower motion.

On 17 August the revised National Planning Policy Framework took effect, and it is stronger than ministers are given credit for. Policy HC6 states that development should not result in the loss of key community facilities, including public houses, unless it can be demonstrated there is no reasonable prospect of the use being retained, and that where commercial viability is the issue, “evidence should be provided that reasonable steps have been taken to market the property for its existing use without success, for a period of at least 12 months”. The consultation draft protected only the last pub in an area. The final version covers all pubs, as the BBC reported when it was published.

Angela Rayner, the Housing Secretary, said at publication: “Pubs are part of who we are as a nation. They’re where we celebrate, grieve, argue and belong, and building the homes we desperately need should never come at the cost of the pubs we love.”

Two months later, on 16 October, Boston council approved an application to convert the Grade II listed Robin Hood Inn into three maisonettes, alongside two existing flats, application B/26/0313. Planning officers concluded: “The applicant does not currently see a commercially viable future for the building as a pub.”

That was a local authority decision, taken under national policy it must treat as a material consideration rather than a rule that fells every conversion, and applications already lodged are not automatically reopened. The published record does not show whether HC6 was applied, whether 12 months of marketing evidence was required and tested, or whether the decision was taken on the pre-August framework. That is exactly why ministers should explain it. The reason given for approval is the judgement HC6 says should be tested against marketing evidence rather than accepted from an owner, and an application determined in October is exactly the case in which the new test should bite.

A comparable case is before councillors in Norfolk, where South Norfolk and Broadland councils are considering an application to turn the closed Gull Inn at Framingham Pigot, an 18th-century Grade II listed building, into a single dwelling with an annexe. The supporting documents argue that “the scale of the premises is … considered greater than the level of trade which could reasonably be expected”.

Neither case involves a minister. Both involve a regime ministers control. An Asset of Community Value listing triggers a right to bid and a six-month moratorium. It gives a community no veto, and it does not keep a pub open.

It is also worth reading the planning figures accurately. These are applications, not closures: some will be refused, some withdrawn, some approved and never built. But the Campaign for Real Ale estimates that as many as a third of pub losses happen without the planning permission the law requires, as The Drinks Business reported, which would make the files a floor rather than a ceiling. Plota has not published its full methodology and the reporting does not state whether the dataset covers England alone, so the 543 should be read as a measure of pressure on pub premises, not a count of graves.

The £870 that is paid to the brewer

Days before the planning figures appeared, the Environment Secretary announced that changes to packaging waste fees “could save pubs up to £870 a year” for a venue selling 10,000 beer bottles and 3,700 wine bottles.

The same announcement, in its notes to editors, sets out the limit. The change takes effect in April 2027. It covers glass sold directly from producers to licensed venues. And “any savings would be realised by the businesses that is responsible for the EPR fees, such as drinks manufacturers, rather than by pubs directly”.

Dame Angela Eagle has ended a double charge, and Emma McClarkin of the BBPA welcomed the direction of travel. But a saving realised by a manufacturer is not a saving received by a publican unless it is passed on, and nothing requires that it is. McClarkin warned that the 12,000 publicans running leased and tenanted pubs must be included, “as otherwise over a quarter of Britain’s pubs will not equally benefit from this important change”.

A Prime Minister who promises the cavalry should be able to say how much of the £870 reaches the bar. He has not said.

The Government was warned

None of this was unforeseen, and the warnings are on the record.

Kate Nicholls of UKHospitality said the sector had repeatedly warned the Treasury before the Budget that hospitality would be uniquely hit by the revaluation, because pandemic-era rents had suppressed the valuations it was built on. “The eye-watering increases pubs, hotels and other venues are now waking up to was exactly the reason why the Treasury had to implement the maximum possible discount,” she said.

The BBPA has asked for permanent business rates reform, a cut in beer duty and VAT, and a lighter regulatory burden, warning that “the scale of these closures is avoidable because pubs are doing a brisk trade, but their profits are wiped out by a disproportionate tax burden and huge costs”. Shadow ministers warned in November 2025 that bills would rise “by a lot”, as the BBC reported at the time. Ministers proceeded, then announced a relief in January, another in July and a third in October, each presented as new support rather than as a partial correction to the last.

On planning, ministers have been warned from the other direction. UKHospitality’s Allen Simpson said the framework may protect buildings without protecting businesses: “You can legislate to stop a pub being sold as a flat but what you can’t do is legislate to force them to stay open if they’re not viable.” He added that without lower running costs, “what we’ll be left with is not pubs which are open but actually empty premises because they can’t be used as a pub or a house.”

That is the trap Labour has built. It has made conversion harder, which is welcome, without making trading easier, which is the only thing that keeps a pub open.

GREAT BRITISH PAC REACTION

Richard Thomson, National Director of Great British PAC, said:

“This Government is strangling businesses with higher costs, heavier taxes and endless uncertainty. But when a pub closes, we lose far more than a business – we lose part of the fabric of Britain.

The local pub is where communities meet, friendships begin and people sit face-to-face to discuss, debate and disagree. It is where loneliness is broken and neighbours become friends.

Ministers can announce relief schemes and headline figures, but publicans need to know what they will actually pay and whether they can survive.

Because once these pubs are demolished or converted, they are gone. You cannot rebuild generations of history, loyalty and community with a government press release.”

A pub is not a line in a planning register. It is the room where a village holds its meetings, where a shift ends, where a wake is held and a pool team is picked. The 543 files in the Plota research are applications to convert or demolish, not completed losses. Only some will be approved, only some of those will be built out, and the 295 closures the BBPA recorded in the first nine months of the year are a separate count. What the planning data shows is a queue of pub buildings whose existing use is under threat, set against 63 applications pointing the other way. That is the balance of pressure, and it is running against the institutions that hold communities together while ministers insist the tide has turned.

This Government deserves credit for one thing. It has gone further on business rates than its predecessor was willing to, and a 35 per cent relief, a higher small business threshold and a two-year freeze are not rounding errors. Great British PAC does not dispute that. What it disputes is the claim, repeated since July, that publicans have been rescued, when the only number ministers will put their name to is an average saving rather than a bill. A relief is not a result. A percentage is not a saving. An average is not a pub.

The timing is not neutral. During 2026/27, the first year of a revaluation that raised pub rateable values by 30 per cent on average, the only pub-specific support was 15 per cent, and 295 pubs closed in nine months. The extra relief begins five months from now, on the day wage costs rise again, and it is promised for two years only, with nothing published about the third. Every publican weighing a sale this winter weighs that gap.

On planning, ministers wrote a better test than their critics expected and have yet to show it enforced. HC6 requires 12 months of marketing evidence before a pub is written off. Two months after it took effect, a Grade II listed pub in Boston was approved for conversion because its owner could not see a commercial future for it. Perhaps the evidence existed and was not summarised. Ministers should say so. What they cannot do is claim to protect community pubs while declining to explain how the first prominent test of that protection was decided.

The £870 is the pattern in miniature. A saving is announced for pubs; the department’s own notes record that it goes to drinks manufacturers, from April 2027, with no guaranteed pass-through. Publicans may ask how much of it they will ever see.

Labour’s failure is not that it has ignored pubs. It is that it governs by announcement and measures itself by its own press releases. The number that matters is not 35 per cent, or £1,100, or £870. It is the bill a landlord opens in April, and no minister has shown what it will say.

GREAT BRITISH PAC DEMANDS

Great British PAC demands that the responsible ministers and authorities:

  1. Publish worked examples for representative pubs. The Chancellor must publish, before 1 April 2027, bills for pubs across rateable value bands showing the revaluation, transitional relief, small business rates relief, the 15 per cent and 35 per cent reliefs and the real-terms freeze in one place, with the cash effect of the increase from 15 to 35 per cent, the distribution of the 32,000 eligible venues across those bands and the methodology behind the £1,100 estimate.
  2. Publish the costings, the funding and the duration. The Treasury must set out the cost of the relief in 2027/28 and 2028/29, the assumed yield from removing vape shops and adult gaming centres from reliefs and raising Machine Games Duty, the contingency if that yield falls short, and its plan for pub relief after 31 March 2029, when the 35 per cent rate as announced is due to end.
  3. Show that the planning protection is being applied. The Housing Secretary must state how many pub conversion decisions have been determined since 17 August 2026, in how many the 12-month marketing requirement in HC6 was applied, and whether she considers the approval of B/26/0313 in Boston consistent with that policy. Her department must publish guidance on the evidence councils should require.
  4. Give publicans the packaging saving directly, or explain why not. The Environment Secretary must publish the mechanism by which the reduction in Extended Producer Responsibility fees reaches tied and tenanted publicans rather than stopping with manufacturers, respond to the BBPA’s warning that 12,000 small publicans may be excluded, and set out what share a pub that does not buy directly from producers can expect.
  5. Report outcomes, not announcements. The Housing and Business Secretaries must publish quarterly figures for pub openings, closures, conversions completed and jobs lost by region and nation, distinguish applications approved from premises actually lost, and set a published target for net closures against which ministerial claims can be tested.

The cavalry was promised in July, confirmed in October and is due in April. The 543 applications in the Plota research were lodged across the 12 months to September. Some will already have been decided, some will be settled by officers under delegated powers, some will be withdrawn, and some will still be live. Each application raises a serious question about the future of a pub building and the pressures facing Britain’s hospitality sector. The publicans deciding whether to fight the rest will be reading a rates bill rather than a Budget red book.

A Government promising to spend £100 million a year on a pub rescue should be able to show what that money will actually deliver. If the relief is as generous as ministers say, publishing the worked example costs them nothing and settles the argument in their favour. If it is not, no amount of cavalry imagery will keep the doors open.

The test is not the size of the announcement. It is whether the lights are on and the till is ringing in April 2028. On the evidence ministers have published so far, they have given the British public no way to test whether their promised rescue will actually work.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here