Small businesses are pulling back on recruitment, payroll employment is falling and young people are struggling to find work as Labour prepares to introduce sweeping new employment laws.
Britain’s jobs market is showing further signs of strain under Labour, with vacancies falling to their lowest level in more than a decade outside the pandemic, as businesses struggle with rising employment costs and prepare for another wave of government regulation.
New figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS), published on Tuesday (17 November), reveal that the number of available jobs fell by 22,000 to just 690,000 in the three months to October.
Excluding the extraordinary disruption caused by Covid lockdowns, the last time vacancies were this low was in 2014.
The figures raise serious questions about the direction of Labour’s economic policies, particularly its decision to increase the cost of employing staff while simultaneously introducing new legal obligations for businesses.
Small firms appear to be bearing the brunt of the downturn, with employers increasingly reluctant to recruit as they contend with higher wage bills, National Insurance contributions and other operating expenses.
The ONS has identified rising costs as an important factor behind the recruitment slowdown, particularly among smaller employers.
For a Government that has repeatedly promised to support working people, the latest statistics expose a troubling contradiction: strengthening employment protections means little to those unable to secure a job in the first place.
Labour’s employment reforms add to pressure
The deteriorating recruitment figures come just weeks before significant changes under Labour’s Employment Rights Act 2025 are due to take effect on 1 January 2027.
Under the legislation, employees will generally become eligible to claim ordinary unfair dismissal after six months of employment rather than the current two years.
The existing statutory cap on compensatory awards for unfair dismissal will also be removed, potentially increasing employers’ financial exposure if they lose a tribunal case.
The Government argues that these changes will improve job security and protect workers from unfair treatment. However, critics warn that increasing the potential costs and legal risks of employing staff could make businesses more cautious about taking on new recruits.
The reforms are particularly concerning for smaller companies without dedicated human resources departments or substantial financial reserves.
Employers will still be able to dismiss staff for legitimate reasons, provided they follow fair procedures, but the additional obligations come at a time when recruitment is already weakening.
Labour’s approach risks creating precisely the opposite outcome to that intended: a labour market in which existing employees have greater protections, but those seeking work face fewer opportunities.
The Government’s decision to increase employers’ National Insurance contributions has already added to the cost of staffing businesses. With further changes approaching, ministers now face uncomfortable questions about whether their policies are discouraging the very recruitment Britain needs.
Payroll employment falls to three-year low
The warning signs extend beyond the number of jobs being advertised.
Provisional figures from HM Revenue and Customs, published by the ONS, show that the number of employees on company payrolls fell by 34,000 in October to approximately 30.2 million, the lowest level since September 2023.
Pay growth is also losing momentum. Average earnings, including bonuses, increased by 3.6 per cent in the three months to September, the weakest annual growth rate in nearly six years.
Once inflation is taken into account, total pay growth was just 0.3 per cent, leaving households with little improvement in their spending power.
Although the overall unemployment rate edged down to 4.6 per cent in the three months to September, falling vacancies and declining payroll numbers suggest employers remain cautious about expanding their workforces.
Young people face a bleak jobs market
The situation is particularly worrying for younger workers.
Unemployment among 18 to 24-year-olds stood at 13 per cent in the three months to September, compared with 10.7 per cent during the same period in 2019, before the pandemic.
Young men are particularly badly affected, with an unemployment rate of 14.2 per cent, compared with 11.6 per cent among young women.
These figures emerge as former Labour Cabinet minister Alan Milburn prepares to publish a major review into the growing number of young people who are not in education, employment or training.
The review is expected to warn that, without significant intervention, the number of young people outside work and education could rise to 1.27 million by 2031.
Mr Milburn’s proposals aim to help hundreds of thousands more young people into employment, education or training over the next decade.
But the central question remains whether Labour can deliver those ambitions while pursuing policies that employers say are making recruitment more expensive.
Young people entering the workplace depend heavily on businesses being willing to offer their first job, apprenticeship or training opportunity. When employers stop recruiting, it is often those without experience who struggle most to get through the door.
Businesses need confidence, not more burdens
The latest figures present an increasingly difficult challenge for Labour.
Ministers insist that stronger workers’ rights will deliver a fairer economy, but the Government must also confront the consequences of higher employment costs at a time when smaller firms are already reducing recruitment.
The ONS figures do not establish that Labour’s policies are solely responsible for the slowdown. Wider economic uncertainty, weak demand and other business pressures are also influencing hiring decisions.
Nevertheless, the evidence that rising costs are affecting recruitment raises legitimate concerns about the Government’s priorities.
Britain needs businesses confident enough to invest, expand and employ more people. Instead, the latest statistics point towards an economy in which employers are becoming increasingly hesitant to create new positions.
For Labour, the uncomfortable reality is that employment rights can only benefit those who have employment.
And with vacancies at their lowest non-pandemic level in 12 years, tens of thousands fewer opportunities available and young unemployment remaining stubbornly high, the Government faces mounting pressure to explain how its policies will encourage businesses to start hiring again.





