Wednesday 18th November 2026 09:11am
Home UK News Smart motorway speed cameras lose approval months after ministers said fix was...

Smart motorway speed cameras lose approval months after ministers said fix was agreed

Overhead gantry with lane signals and a speed camera sign above the M1 smart motorway in Nottinghamshire
A smart motorway gantry with a speed camera on the M1 in Nottinghamshire, 2022. Photo: Ed6767 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Advertisement Buy Now

The variable speed cameras on England’s smart motorways are being taken out of use for enforcement, less than a year after ministers told MPs that a Home Office-approved fix for a fault in the system had been agreed.

The Home Office has revoked the system’s approval after a second potential fault was found, and an independent review dated July, but published only on Tuesday, lists ten missed chances to deal with the first.

In a written statement on Tuesday, the roads minister, Justin Madders, said the Home Office had withdrawn the system’s type approval, which lets camera readings be accepted more easily as evidence in court, because the problems “could not be addressed to their satisfaction in any reasonable timeframe”.

National Highways, the government-owned company that runs England’s motorways, is ending its contract with the supplier, Verra Mobility, to use the cameras for enforcement and is “considering all further commercial and legal options”. According to the BBC, the new fault affects every variable speed camera on smart motorways, along with the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge, and Mr Madders admitted the system will not be fully fixed until some time next year.

Parliament was told something very different last December. Announcing the first fault, Mr Madders’s predecessor, Simon Lightwood, said on 16 December 2025: “A Home Office-approved solution to this issue has now been agreed.”

The first fault was not small. Cameras wait about 17 seconds before recognising a new limit, so when the gantry signs changed and changed back within that window, the camera kept enforcing the old, lower limit. The review by Tracy Westall found it affected 154 cameras in 22 police force areas and caused 2,650 wrongful camera activations between 2021 and 2025. Not every activation led to a fine, and ministers have promised refunds and the removal of wrongly applied penalty points.

It came to light only because one motorist fought back. On 25 January 2025, Avon and Somerset Police told National Highways that a driver accused of breaking a 40mph limit on the M5 had dashcam footage showing 50mph on the gantry. The review says that without that footage, the case “would have resulted in wrongful prosecution”.

Ms Westall counts ten missed opportunities. The first came at the design and testing stage, when the problem “should reasonably have been anticipated”. The other nine came during 2025. National Highways settled on a theory of a single faulty sensor without “any demonstrable data analysis”, staff who offered other explanations were “seemingly not being heard”, and in August its own lawyers raised concerns that were “not immediately acted on”.

Executives were first told on 9 June. The Department for Transport and ministers were told on 10 September, ministers learned on 13 October that it was a national problem, and the 22 affected police forces were not notified until 3 November, more than nine months after the first warning.

Labour is right that the cameras were upgraded from 2019, under the Conservatives, and Mr Madders made a point of saying so. But Labour has been the Government since July 2024. Every missed opportunity after the design stage happened on its watch, at a company it owns and oversees, and it was Labour ministers who told MPs a fix had been agreed.

The review itself is dated July 2026 but was released only with this week’s statement. The Department says Ms Westall looked again after the second fault emerged and found her recommendations “remain valid and unchanged”.

Then there is the money. Contracts Finder shows National Highways awarded Redflex Traffic Systems, backed by Verra Mobility, a £25.5 million contract in March 2024 to maintain and develop the cameras until 2028, and £7.3 million in July 2024 to develop their replacement. Both predate Labour. Ministers have not said how much is now at risk, or whether any can be recovered.

Mr Madders insists “drivers will see no difference”, with extra traffic officer patrols, CCTV and number plate cameras, and police mobile cameras. But the review notes the same cameras enforce lane closures as well as speed limits, and the statement does not say how closed lanes on smart motorways will now be policed.

Rod Dennis of the RAC told the BBC that malfunctioning cameras “further undermine confidence” in roads that drivers already have serious misgivings about.

Ministers have still not said how many drivers were actually fined or given points, how much has been paid back, or what the investigation back to 2019 ordered last December has found. Nor have they said when smart motorway speed limits will again be enforced by camera.

Image: A smart motorway gantry with a speed camera on the M1 in Nottinghamshire, 2022. Photo: Ed6767 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here