Court acknowledges Britain’s “long and shameful history” of mistreating Chagossians but blocks latest legal challenge. Great British PAC condemns Government’s treatment of islanders as fight for justice heads towards the Privy Council.
The Chagossian people have suffered another bitter legal defeat in their fight for their ancestral homeland after the Court of Appeal refused to allow their latest challenge against the British Government to proceed.
In a judgment handed down on Friday, 20 November, Lady Justice Andrews dismissed applications brought by Chagossian claimants seeking to challenge the Government’s failure to reconsider their rights to return to the islands before any transfer of sovereignty to Mauritius.
The decision represents another painful chapter in the decades-long battle of a people forcibly removed from their homeland by Britain, and now facing the prospect of their islands being transferred to Mauritius without their consent.
The ruling comes as Labour Prime Minister Andy Burnham continues discussions over the controversial sovereignty agreement originally signed under his predecessor, Sir Keir Starmer.
Although the treaty remains unratified and the Government is reviewing its terms, the dispute over the Chagossians’ ancestral rights remains unresolved.
For the islanders, the central question is painfully simple: how can Britain acknowledge the historic injustice of their removal while continuing to defend legal restrictions that prevent them from returning home?
Court acknowledges Britain’s shameful treatment
In her judgment, Lady Justice Andrews referred to the “long and shameful history to the treatment of the inhabitants of the Chagos Islands”.
The Chagossians were forcibly displaced during the 1960s and 1970s after Britain established the British Indian Ocean Territory and made Diego Garcia available for American military purposes.
Thousands of islanders and their descendants were left living in exile, including in Mauritius, the Seychelles and Britain.
Despite numerous legal battles, restrictions imposed in 2004 continue to prevent Chagossians from enjoying a right of abode in their ancestral territory.
The latest proceedings involved Louis Michel Mandarin and his son Louis Misley Mandarin, alongside a separate claim brought by Chagossian campaigner Bertrice Pompe.
Their legal challenge arose against the background of the Government’s agreement with Mauritius and its failure to reconsider whether the restrictions on Chagossian residence and resettlement should remain in place.
The claimants argued that circumstances had fundamentally changed, particularly because the proposed agreement envisaged the possibility of resettlement on the outer islands under Mauritian sovereignty.
However, Lady Justice Andrews upheld the earlier refusal to allow their judicial review claims to proceed.
The court concluded that most of their arguments were effectively challenges to the decision-making process surrounding the treaty, an area in which the courts could not intervene in the manner sought.
It also ruled that the claimants had failed to establish an arguable legal obligation requiring the Government to reconsider the 2004 restrictions.
The ruling did not determine whether the proposed handover was politically justified, nor did it grant approval for the transfer of sovereignty.
The extraordinary contradiction over resettlement
Perhaps the most significant aspect of the judgment concerns the arguments historically used to prevent the Chagossians from returning.
For years, successive British governments cited national security concerns, environmental risks and the substantial costs of establishing viable communities on the remote islands.
Yet the treaty signed with Mauritius in May 2025 envisaged that Mauritius could permit resettlement on islands other than Diego Garcia.
Lady Justice Andrews observed that the agreement appeared to indicate that both governments accepted resettlement might be feasible without compromising the security of the strategically important American military base.
The judge also considered the claimants’ argument on the assumption, without deciding the disputed facts, that national security was no longer regarded as an absolute obstacle to resettlement.
For campaigners, the apparent contradiction is extraordinary.
If the islands can potentially accommodate resettlement under Mauritian sovereignty, why should the people whose families lived there for generations be denied the opportunity to return while the territory remains British?
The court concluded that the Government was not legally obliged to restore rights of abode simply because circumstances may have changed.
It also found that ministers could rationally regard future resettlement as a matter for Mauritius if sovereignty were transferred.
But that legal conclusion leaves a profound moral question unanswered.
Why should a displaced people have to rely on the decisions of another government to determine whether they can ever live on their ancestral land?
Labour’s controversial Mauritius agreement
The sovereignty agreement was signed on 22 May 2025 under former Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer.
Under its original terms, Mauritius would receive sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago, while Britain would retain rights over Diego Garcia for an initial 99 years to ensure the continued operation of the UK-US military base.
The agreement followed longstanding Mauritian sovereignty claims and international legal pressure arising from the islands’ separation from Mauritius before its independence.
However, Chagossian campaigners opposing the agreement argue that the interests and wishes of the displaced islanders have not been adequately protected.
Particular concerns have been raised about British Chagossians who do not hold Mauritian nationality and what rights they would have to enter, reside in or resettle their ancestral homeland under Mauritian control.
The original agreement has since stalled.
The implementing legislation was dropped in April 2026 following a change in the American Government’s position, and Britain announced a review in September.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has subsequently said he wants to recast the arrangements with Mauritius, particularly to address American concerns about the security of Diego Garcia.
He has continued discussions with Mauritian Prime Minister Navin Ramgoolam, with the Government seeking progress on a revised arrangement.
Nevertheless, the Chagossians’ fundamental concerns about their ancestral rights remain.
Campaigners argue that any future agreement must put the wishes and interests of the islanders at its heart, rather than treating them as an issue to be settled solely between London and Port Louis.
Government seeks costs from islanders
Adding to the disappointment, the Chagossians’ solicitor has confirmed that the British Government is seeking legal costs following the unsuccessful proceedings.
The question of costs has not yet been determined.
The prospect of further financial liabilities is another blow to islanders who have spent years fighting through the courts to secure recognition of their rights.
The Great British PAC has been among the organisations helping to support the Chagossians’ campaign, raising substantial funds towards legal proceedings and other assistance.
Its support has included helping to finance legal challenges concerning the future of the islands and assisting Chagossians involved in the continuing dispute.
Great British PAC condemns Labour’s treatment of Chagossians
Claire Bullivant, CEO of the Great British PAC, condemned the latest developments and called on Prime Minister Burnham to put the interests of the islanders first.
She said: “This is an absolute disgrace. Britain forcibly removed these people from their ancestral homeland, denied them the right to return for decades, and now, under this Labour Government, they are being forced to fight through the courts simply to reclaim rights that should never have been taken away.
“The sheer cruelty of it is staggering. The court itself acknowledges Britain’s shameful treatment of the Chagossians, yet this Government continues to defend the very restrictions that keep them from their homes, while seeking legal costs from those brave enough to challenge it.
“And the hypocrisy is breathtaking. Apparently, the Chagos Islands can be suitable for resettlement when Mauritius is in charge, but not when the Chagossians themselves want to return. How can any British Prime Minister defend that?
“The Labour Government should hang its head in shame. Instead of standing up for British Chagossians, it has pursued a deal that would hand sovereignty over their ancestral homeland to Mauritius without securing their consent.
“Prime Minister Andy Burnham now has an opportunity to put right this historic injustice. His Government should be standing alongside these British citizens, not fighting them through the courts while seeking to recover legal costs from people who have already suffered so much.
“These are not bargaining chips in some diplomatic negotiation. They are human beings. They are British citizens. Their families were driven from their homes, and they deserve justice, dignity and a meaningful say in the future of their islands.
“The Great British PAC is proud of the support we have given these courageous islanders. Today’s ruling is a bitter disappointment, but it is not the end of their fight. The Privy Council appeal offers another opportunity to challenge the injustice they face.
“A nation that can acknowledge a historic wrong but refuses to put it right has learned absolutely nothing from its history. The Chagossians have waited more than half a century for justice. How much longer does this Government expect them to wait?”
Fight now moves towards the Privy Council
Despite Friday’s setback, another potentially significant legal battle remains.
Attention is turning to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council following separate proceedings concerning Chagossians who returned to Île du Coin earlier this year.
The islanders established a presence on the remote island in February, prompting the British Indian Ocean Territory authorities to issue removal notices because they did not have the necessary immigration permits.
In March, the territory’s Chief Justice ruled in their favour on important aspects of their legal challenge, including finding the constitutional prohibition on their right of abode unlawful.
However, that decision was overturned by the BIOT Court of Appeal on 12 November.
The Chagossians’ legal representatives are now pursuing the possibility of an appeal to the Privy Council.
Tumbridge has indicated that the latest English judgment contained some encouraging observations, particularly concerning the changing circumstances surrounding resettlement and national security.
He nevertheless acknowledged that the outcome was not what the claimants had hoped for.
A possible fresh legal challenge focused specifically on the 2004 restrictions has also been discussed, although no such proceedings have been announced.
That route would face substantial difficulties, with Lady Justice Andrews making clear that even a more precisely formulated challenge to an earlier refusal to reconsider rights of abode would have failed on the arguments before her.
For now, the separate Privy Council proceedings offer the next potential avenue for the Chagossians to contest the legal restrictions affecting their return.
A historic injustice still waiting to be put right
Friday’s ruling leaves the Chagossians facing an uncomfortable reality.
The British courts recognise the shameful history of their displacement. The possibility of resettlement on the outer islands is acknowledged. Yet the restrictions preventing the islanders from exercising a right of abode remain in place.
The court’s judgment does not mean that the Chagossians should never be permitted to return.
It means that the particular legal challenges brought before the English courts have failed to establish grounds on which judicial review could proceed.
There remains an important distinction between what ministers are legally required to do and what they could choose to do politically.
The proposed sovereignty transfer is not yet complete, and the British Government is actively reconsidering the arrangements with Mauritius.
That gives Prime Minister Burnham an opportunity to address the question of Chagossian rights before any revised agreement is concluded.
Mauritius maintains its longstanding claim to sovereignty over the archipelago, a position supported by the International Court of Justice’s 2019 advisory opinion on decolonisation.
But questions of sovereignty cannot erase the experience of the people who were removed from the islands, nor the concerns of those who fear that decisions about their future will again be made without their agreement.
For the Chagossians, this is not simply a dispute over diplomatic agreements, military installations or competing sovereignty claims.
It is about their families, their history, their homes and whether they will ever be permitted to return to the land from which they were expelled.
After more than half a century of displacement, Britain has acknowledged the injustice.
The question now is whether its Government will use the opportunity presented by the review of the Mauritius agreement to take meaningful steps towards putting it right.
The Chagossians have lost another legal battle.
Their fight for their homeland continues.






Sky news – Ed Conway: What has Brexit done to Britains economy?