Wednesday 18th November 2026 09:11am
Home World Argentina points to Chagos as it tries to halt Falklands oil

Argentina points to Chagos as it tries to halt Falklands oil

Aerial view of Stanley, the capital of the Falkland Islands, beside its harbour
Stanley, Falkland Islands, from the air. Photo: Tom L-C via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
Advertisement Buy Now

Argentina has urged an international tribunal to apply the reasoning of the Chagos case to the Falkland Islands, as it tries to stop the islands’ first oilfield before drilling begins.

Judges in Hamburg will rule on 28 November, and a Foreign Office minister has declined to tell MPs whether the Foreign Secretary has discussed Britain’s defence with the Attorney General.

At a two-day hearing of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea last week, Argentina’s lawyer, Professor Marcelo Kohen, drew the judges to a 2021 ruling by a special chamber of the same tribunal, which leaned on UN decolonisation resolutions to treat Mauritius as having the stronger claim to the Chagos Archipelago.

Speaking through an interpreter on 11 November, he accepted that “these two situations are not identical”, but told them to “replace ‘Mauritius’ and ‘Chagos’ with ‘Malvinas'” and apply the same reasoning to the Falklands.

That should worry anyone who cares about Britain’s overseas territories, because the Chagos route worked. A 2019 advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice and the 2021 Hamburg ruling were the legal ground Mauritius stood on before Britain agreed to give the islands up. Talks began under the Conservatives in 2022. But it was Labour that signed the handover treaty in May 2025.

Professor Kohen went further. He told the judges the UN General Assembly “has ruled out the application of the right of peoples to self-determination to the current inhabitants of the territory”. In 2013, on a 92 per cent turnout, 99.8 per cent of Falkland Islanders voted to remain British. Three people voted against.

Argentina began arbitration against Britain on 28 September and on 13 October asked the Hamburg tribunal for emergency orders to stop work on the Sea Lion field, more than 100 miles north of the islands. The project is run by Israel’s Navitas Petroleum with Britain’s Rockhopper Exploration. Drilling is due to begin next March, with oil flowing a year later.

Britain fought the case hard. The Attorney General, Ellie Reeves, led the British team in person and told the judges: “The United Kingdom has no doubt about its sovereignty over the Falkland Islands.” She said Argentina’s demands “would have devastating consequences for the Falkland Islands and its people”, and quoted President Milei telling the UN in September that Argentina was “going to take matters into our own hands”.

Britain’s lawyers argued the tribunal has no jurisdiction, because Argentina’s real complaint is about who owns the islands, not the law of the sea.

The stakes are high. Britain told the tribunal that any order to suspend drilling would mean the project “as a whole would not survive”, citing Navitas’s chief executive. An assessment produced for the Falklands puts the boost to the islands’ economy over the life of the project at more than £8 billion. Britain said 120 jobs a year would be lost and that Rockhopper has more than $1 billion invested.

To answer Argentina’s claim of urgency, Britain also gave the tribunal assurances. It confirmed there will be no drilling before 21 March 2027, and that “no further licences will be granted as the licensing regime is suspended”. New Falklands licences need the Foreign Secretary’s consent. Britain did not say in open court when the suspension began or why. The last production licence was issued in 2009.

In the Commons, Conservative MP Ben Obese-Jecty asked what discussions the Foreign Secretary had held with the Attorney General on Britain’s response to Argentina’s bid. Foreign Office minister Uma Kumaran replied on 13 November by citing the Law Officers’ Convention, under which “the fact of, and substance of advice from, the law officers of the Crown is not disclosed outside government”. The Attorney General had argued the case in Hamburg three days earlier.

Downing Street has insisted “the hearing is not about the sovereignty of the Falklands”. Argentina’s lawyers built much of their case around it.

Under the law of the sea convention, countries “shall comply promptly” with emergency orders from the tribunal. Ministers have not said what Britain would do if the judges order work at Sea Lion to stop, or when the islands’ licensing regime will reopen. Labour agreed to give up Chagos after rulings in The Hague and Hamburg. The awkward question is what it would do if Hamburg now rules against the Falklands.

The judges will read their order in Hamburg at 11am on Saturday 28 November. The first well is due to be drilled 113 days later.

Image: Stanley, Falkland Islands, from the air. Photo by Tom L-C, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here