Sunday 22nd November 2026 17:11pm
Home Columnists CLOWNING STREET: WEEK 18 – This Week’s Madness from ‘No Answer Andy’...

CLOWNING STREET: WEEK 18 – This Week’s Madness from ‘No Answer Andy’ and His Labour Circus

Advertisement Buy Now

No Answer Andy’s Brussels Circus, Where Brexit Disappears, Jobs Vanish and the Taxpayer Pays for the Clowns…

Welcome back, dear readers, to another riotous week beneath Westminster’s Big Top of Blunders, where No Answer Andy is performing his most spectacular disappearing act yet, the Brexit referendum is being quietly stuffed into a magician’s hat, the Treasury jugglers are dropping billions, and the Labour contortionists are bending so far backwards towards Brussels that somebody really ought to call an ambulance.

Eighteen weeks into this increasingly expensive freak show, the ringmaster is still promising that Britain will not rejoin the European Union. Which is fascinating, because he appears determined to recreate as many of the arrangements of membership as possible, only without the inconvenient business of actually having a vote on the rules.

This week, Burnham headed to Brussels to advance agreements covering food standards, carbon trading and youth mobility. The proposed arrangements could require Britain to follow changing EU regulations in certain sectors, while potentially making financial contributions to European schemes. Yet the full legal texts, financial commitments and detailed economic assessments have not all been made publicly available. Ministers argue that closer cooperation will remove trade barriers and boost growth. But there is a rather obvious question. If this is such a magnificent deal for Britain, why not publish the whole thing and let the country examine it before Parliament is asked to approve the necessary legislation?

Roll up, roll up, for the amazing Brexit disappearing act! Britain leaves the European Union, follows more of its rules, potentially pays into its arrangements and watches Brussels write regulations over which British ministers have no formal vote. No Answer Andy still insists this is not rejoining. However, the resemblance is becoming rather difficult to ignore.

It is rather like leaving the circus, handing back your membership card, then agreeing to pay the ringmaster, follow his instructions and return every Friday to clean out the elephant enclosure.

And just when the Brexit contortionists thought they had perfected their routine, the RSPCA arrived with some decidedly unwelcome news. The charity has warned that Labour’s EU food agreement could jeopardise planned improvements to animal welfare, including proposals affecting cages for laying hens, farrowing crates for pigs, fur imports and certain slaughter practices. The Government has secured protections for some existing measures, but the RSPCA fears that future British improvements could be constrained by regulatory alignment.

Think about that. A Government that endlessly lectures the country about compassion may be putting its own ability to strengthen animal welfare protections at risk in pursuit of closer relations with Brussels. Millions of hens and pigs could be affected if the proposed reforms cannot proceed. The circus elephant is appalled, the performing seals have lodged a complaint, and even the balloon animals are demanding an explanation.

Meanwhile, the immigration clown has performed a U-turn so spectacular that it deserves its own Olympic category. Having scrapped the Conservatives’ Rwanda deportation scheme, Labour now finds Burnham expressing interest in a European initiative involving Rwanda after five countries reached an agreement in principle on a migrant return hub. The schemes are not identical, and the European proposal concerns people whose asylum claims have been rejected. Nevertheless, the political irony is delicious. Labour spent years denouncing the very idea of offshore arrangements, only to discover that when European governments consider something similar, it suddenly becomes worthy of interest.

More than 88,000 people have crossed the Channel since Labour took office, according to the figures cited by Conservative Party chairman Kevin Hollinrake. No Answer Andy’s response appears to be another magnificent balloon animal labelled TOUGHER BORDERS. Unfortunately, the balloon keeps floating across the Channel while the Government searches for somebody to hold the string.

Back in Britain, the economic circus is providing rather less entertainment. Job vacancies have fallen to around 690,000, their lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014. Businesses are struggling with higher employment costs, young people are finding it harder to get a foothold in the labour market, and the Government is contemplating a youth employment programme whose projected gross annual spending could reach £5.8 billion by 2036/37.

The extraordinary part is that Labour’s own increase in employers’ National Insurance has made hiring more expensive, while its commissioned review now recommends incentives and possible tax relief to encourage businesses to employ young people. So the Government increases the cost of hiring, discovers employers are hiring less, then considers spending taxpayers’ money to persuade them to hire again.

Ladies and gentlemen, behold the amazing Labour employment machine. First it digs a hole, then it announces a multimillion-pound initiative to manufacture ladders.

And while British youngsters struggle to find work, Burnham is negotiating a new EU youth mobility arrangement without yet publishing a full assessment of its likely effects on the domestic labour market. Such schemes can offer opportunities to British and European participants alike, but the Government should explain the proposed numbers, conditions and safeguards. Apparently, asking for the details before signing another international agreement is considered terribly old-fashioned beneath this particular big top.

Families are hardly celebrating either. Inflation has increased, raising concerns about the outlook for interest rates and mortgage costs before Christmas. Analysis also suggests that the inflation-adjusted value of the average British home has fallen by around £63,000 from its earlier peak. That is a comparison of purchasing power over time, not a £63,000 cash loss caused by Labour, but it illustrates how inflation can erode household wealth even when nominal house prices appear relatively resilient.

The Treasury clown insists everything is improving. The homeowner looks at the mortgage statement, the shopping bill and the heating costs, and wonders whether the clown has accidentally wandered into somebody else’s economy.

Over in the housing ring, Angela Rayner has managed to create a potential bureaucratic trap worthy of a professional contortionist. Under one set of rules, landlords recovering a property to sell it face restrictions on letting it again. Under another, councils can seek management powers over qualifying homes left empty for six months, subject to tribunal approval and safeguards. The result could leave some owners caught between restrictions on renting and pressure to bring an unsold property back into use. Only Labour could produce a situation in which somebody might be prevented from renting out a house and then face intervention because it has not been rented out.

And the contradictions keep coming. Labour wants sixteen-year-olds to vote, yet proposals for additional employment permissions could make it harder for some teenagers to obtain ordinary Saturday jobs. Apparently, a young person may be considered sufficiently mature to help choose the Government, but serving a cup of tea requires another encounter with the clipboard brigade.

Then there is Britain’s disappearing pub trade. Planning data cited this week suggests that roughly nine pubs are being considered for conversion for every one planned to open. These are planning proposals, not proof that nine pubs have actually closed for every new opening, but the figures underline the pressures facing an institution at the heart of British communities. Hospitality businesses are already battling costs and uncertainty, while ministers have yet to publish the full details of promised changes affecting the sector. The Labour circus appears determined to protect the Great British pub by making it increasingly difficult to keep one open.

Even the second-home tax has produced an unexpected financial backflip. Around 20,000 properties have reportedly disappeared from the relevant council tax records following the introduction of higher charges, leaving an estimated £48 million gap between anticipated and recorded revenue. Changes in classification and ownership arrangements complicate the figures, but the lesson is familiar. Governments announce a new tax, predict an enormous windfall, then discover that taxpayers do not always behave exactly as the Treasury’s spreadsheet anticipated.

And speaking of spending, NHS Employers has warned that proposed changes to employment rules could impose approximately £900 million in additional annual costs on the health service. The reforms are intended to protect workers from insecure contracts, a legitimate objective, but hospitals rely on flexible staffing arrangements. Great British PAC has challenged ministers over the potential consequences for patients and public safety. At a time when the NHS is desperate for resources, the prospect of hundreds of millions being absorbed by additional administrative and employment costs deserves serious scrutiny. The circus accountant has apparently found another £900 million behind the sofa, although nobody has explained whose sofa it is.

The welfare elephant has also returned, larger than ever. Official figures cited this week show around 1.26 million foreign nationals receiving Universal Credit, while the full financial implications of concessions affecting migrant care workers’ settlement arrangements remain unclear. Foreign nationals include people lawfully living and working in Britain, and the claimant total is not itself a measure of abuse. But when ministers make decisions affecting future eligibility and settlement, taxpayers are entitled to transparent costings rather than another performance from the Amazing Invisible Calculator.

Then comes policing, where Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s proposed merger of forces has prompted Conservative warnings that the changes could leave around 130,000 additional crimes unsolved each year. That figure is an Opposition projection, not an established consequence, but it deserves a proper Government response. The public wants criminals caught, neighbourhood officers visible and crimes investigated. Instead, Westminster is discussing another enormous reorganisation, apparently convinced that the answer to every problem is to make the bureaucracy bigger.

And finally, the Chagos Islands, where the political circus becomes something far more troubling. Chagossians fighting for the right to remain in their ancestral homeland have suffered another legal defeat as Labour continues its negotiations with Mauritius over sovereignty. The Government maintains that its approach will protect the strategically vital Diego Garcia military base, but serious questions remain about the rights of the islanders and the wisdom of transferring sovereignty. More than fifty years after the forced displacement of the Chagossian people, their future is still being argued over in courtrooms and diplomatic meetings. This is no laughing matter, and the Government owes them far more than another carefully rehearsed statement.

And so ends Week Eighteen beneath Westminster’s Big Top of Blunders. Burnham is edging closer to Brussels while insisting Britain is not returning to the EU. Animal welfare protections face uncertainty, the Rwanda policy debate has come full circle, jobs are disappearing, mortgages are hurting, landlords are caught in regulatory knots, pubs are under pressure, and the Treasury is still trying to make its sums add up.

No Answer Andy remains in the centre ring, naturally, wearing his enormous red nose and waving a magnificent balloon animal labelled BRITISH INDEPENDENCE. Behind him, the Brexit contortionists are bending towards Brussels, the immigration clown is booking a flight to Rwanda, the employment magician is searching for 690,000 vacancies, and the Treasury jugglers are attempting to catch another £900 million before it lands on the NHS.

The welfare elephant is sitting on the national balance sheet, the housing clown is trying to rent a house he has been told not to rent, and the pub landlord has packed up his beer pumps because the circus has finally become too expensive to run.

Eighteen weeks into this extraordinary Labour production, the ringmaster is still promising that Britain is moving forward.

Unfortunately, he appears to be marching backwards towards Brussels.

Same circus. Bigger bills. More broken promises.

And No Answer Andy is still pretending he cannot see the elephant in the room.

Or, increasingly, the European Union flag hanging above the tent.

READ ALL ABOUT IT: Links to this week’s top Labour circus acts below:

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here