
Labour’s much-trumpeted EU reset has come under fierce criticism from one of Britain’s leading animal welfare charities, which warns that millions of farm animals could continue to suffer in cages and confinement because of the Government’s decision to align British regulations with Brussels.
Plans to end cruel cages for hens and pigs, restrict fur and foie gras imports and improve slaughter practices are facing an uncertain future after Labour agreed to bring Britain back into alignment with EU rules.
The RSPCA has expressed deep disappointment over the agreement reached at the UK–EU summit in Brussels on Friday, November 20, warning that hard-won opportunities to improve animal welfare following Brexit are now in jeopardy.
At the heart of the controversy is Labour’s failure to secure an explicit exemption allowing Britain to introduce tougher animal welfare legislation independently of the European Union.
The agreement is intended to remove costly checks and paperwork on food, animals and agricultural products moving between Britain and the EU.
However, critics fear the price of reducing bureaucracy could be paid by millions of animals, while British farmers seeking to maintain higher welfare standards may find themselves competing against cheaper imports produced under less demanding rules.
The Government’s own published explanation confirms that the agreement will cover animal welfare and operate through dynamic alignment, meaning Britain and the EU will apply the same rules in the areas covered by the deal.
Although specific protections have been negotiated for the existing ban on live animal exports and measures against puppy smuggling, no comparable general exemption for future animal welfare improvements appears in the Government’s published list.
Ten million hens and 200,000 pigs could remain confined
Among the RSPCA’s biggest concerns are plans to phase out cages for laying hens and farrowing crates for pigs.
According to the charity, approximately 10 million hens remain in enriched cages across the UK, restricting their ability to move freely, forage, dust bathe and carry out other natural behaviours.
Around 200,000 breeding pigs also give birth and nurse their piglets in farrowing crates each year.
These restrictive enclosures prevent sows from turning around freely and significantly limit their ability to perform natural behaviours such as nest-building.
Britain had been considering further restrictions on both practices, offering the prospect of substantial improvements to the lives of millions of farm animals.
But the RSPCA now fears that the EU agreement could prevent or discourage the Government from delivering those changes.
The charity also warns that British farmers investing in higher welfare systems could face competition from imported products produced using methods Britain wishes to prohibit.
For a Labour Government that has repeatedly spoken of improving animal welfare, the prospect of leaving millions of hens and pigs in restrictive housing raises serious questions about its priorities.
Cruel pig stunning method could remain in use
Another major concern is the continued use of high-concentration carbon dioxide gas to stun pigs before slaughter.
The RSPCA says the method causes severe distress, while the Government’s Animal Welfare Committee has concluded that it causes avoidable pain, distress or suffering.
Ministers had committed to consulting on phasing out the practice, with possible alternatives including argon gas and improved electrical stunning methods.
Yet those ambitions may now be harder to deliver under a system requiring alignment with EU legislation.
The Government must now explain how it intends to honour its animal welfare commitments without breaching the regulatory obligations it has accepted.
Labour’s foie gras reversal raises serious questions
Perhaps one of the clearest examples of the consequences of the reset concerns foie gras.
Producing foie gras by force-feeding ducks and geese is already prohibited in Britain on animal welfare grounds.
Nevertheless, importing and selling foie gras produced through those methods overseas remains legal.
Labour had previously promised to close that loophole.
Before entering government, Labour’s then shadow environment secretary Steve Reed pledged to ban commercial imports of foie gras produced by force-feeding, condemning the practice in unequivocal terms.
However, reports ahead of Friday’s summit revealed that ministers were abandoning plans for an import ban to help secure the trade agreement with Brussels.
The contradiction is difficult to ignore.
Britain considers the force-feeding of ducks and geese sufficiently cruel to prohibit its use domestically, yet products made through that same practice can continue to be imported and sold.
Rather than using Britain’s post-Brexit freedoms to end that inconsistency, Labour’s EU reset appears to have made resolving it considerably harder.
The RSPCA also fears that plans to ban imports and sales of farmed fur will be lost, despite Britain having prohibited fur farming for years.
Millions of pounds’ worth of animal fur continues to enter the British market, including products originating from farming systems condemned by animal welfare campaigners.
Without additional protections, the charity believes that the proposed bans on fur and foie gras imports will not proceed.
RSPCA condemns Government’s failure to protect animal welfare
David Bowles, the RSPCA’s Head of Public Affairs, said:
“This deal is not good news for future farm animal welfare standards and for those farmers who wish to produce under higher animal welfare standards.”
He warned that the UK risked losing the ability to improve standards while allowing cheaper products from farming systems with lower welfare requirements to compete with British producers.
The charity is calling on ministers to honour commitments to improve conditions for laying hens and pigs, introduce clearer food production labelling and end the use of carbon dioxide stunning.
The RSPCA also wants the Government to protect British farmers who invest in higher welfare standards, rather than leaving them exposed to unfair competition.
Bowles said: “We are incredibly disappointed to see that we will lose these vital protections for animals and the UK may not be able to call itself a global leader on animal welfare.”
Government celebrates reduced red tape – but at what cost?
The Labour Government argues that the agreement will benefit British businesses by removing trade barriers and reducing paperwork.
Its published assessment estimates that the deal could increase UK GDP by up to 0.14 per cent by 2040 compared with projected levels without the agreement, while making it easier for British food and agricultural businesses to export to European markets.
The arrangements are scheduled to take effect on March 1, 2028, subject to the necessary UK and EU procedures.
There are also some benefits for animals and pet owners.
Britain’s existing prohibition on exporting livestock and horses for slaughter or fattening outside the British Islands will be protected by a specific exemption.
Measures to tackle puppy and kitten smuggling have also been safeguarded, while a new pet passport system should make travel between Britain and EU countries easier and cheaper.
But these protections only underline the central question facing Labour.
If the Government was able to negotiate exceptions for existing animal welfare protections, why did it not secure sufficient flexibility to introduce stronger protections in the future?
And why should cutting paperwork take precedence over ending practices that Britain’s leading animal welfare organisations have spent years campaigning against?
Has Labour surrendered one of Brexit’s biggest opportunities?
Leaving the European Union gave Britain greater freedom to establish its own animal welfare rules.
That independence helped make possible the Animal Welfare (Livestock Exports) Act 2024, which banned the export of certain live animals for slaughter and fattening.
It also created opportunities to go further than existing EU standards in areas such as farming practices, animal imports and food production.
Now Labour’s decision to embrace regulatory alignment threatens to restrict some of those opportunities.
The RSPCA’s concerns do not establish that every proposed reform has been legally prohibited. The precise consequences for individual measures will depend on the agreement’s scope and implementation.
Nevertheless, the absence of a broad exemption for future animal welfare legislation represents a significant concern, particularly when ministers had been considering measures that could directly benefit millions of animals.
It also raises an uncomfortable political question: what is the point of having the freedom to improve animal welfare standards after Brexit if the Government voluntarily accepts new restrictions on exercising that freedom?
Labour may see closer alignment with Brussels as a means of reducing trade friction and improving economic relations.
But for the millions of animals still confined in cages, crates or subjected to distressing slaughter methods, the consequences could be very different.
Britain’s reputation for animal welfare has been built through decades of campaigning, legislation and public pressure. It should not become a bargaining chip in negotiations designed primarily to make trade easier.
The RSPCA is urging the Prime Minister to reconsider the Government’s approach and deliver the improvements promised in its 2025 Animal Welfare Strategy.
For Labour, the challenge is now straightforward: demonstrate that its EU reset will not come at the expense of British farmers, higher welfare standards and the millions of animals whose lives those standards are intended to improve.
Reducing red tape may be a legitimate objective. But if the price is abandoning the chance to end cruel and outdated farming practices, the Government will have serious questions to answer.




